A bearded warehouse worker in a beige work coat in an aisle

Three Years on Reach Trucks Tells You Less Than You Think

Blog4 min readTeam Radius Hire

In short

  • Years of experience is one of the weakest predictors of overall job performance in the research. It is also one of the most common filters in frontline hiring.
  • Experience still matters, and so do certificates. But the number of years tells you little about how someone actually did the work.
  • Stop filtering on years. Ask about the work.

“Minimum two years’ experience on reach trucks.”

It is in thousands of job ads. It is in agency search filters. And when a CV says "three years on reach trucks", it often decides who gets a call back and who does not.

We think it deserves much less weight than it gets.

What the research says about years

In 2022, Sackett and colleagues revised the main research estimates on how well different selection methods predict overall job performance. On their figures, years of job experience has an average validity of 0.07. The earlier, widely cited estimate from 1998 was 0.18. For comparison, structured interviews average 0.42.

Validity is a correlation between what a method says about candidates and how they later perform. 0 means no relationship. So 0.07 is close to nothing.

Two honest caveats, because they matter:

  • These are averages across many studies, mostly outside the Netherlands and across many occupations. Results vary.
  • The number is about years as a predictor on its own. It says nothing against licences, certificates or safety training, which matter for working safely and legally regardless.

Why years get so much weight anyway

Years are easy. On a busy screening day, a date range on a CV turns into a number in two seconds, and a number feels objective. It is also easy to put in a job ad, easy for an agency to filter on, and easy to defend: "we asked for two years, they had two years."

But "three years on reach trucks" can mean very different things. Three years moving pallets at floor level, or three years putting away at twelve metres. Three years in a site with strict pre use checks, or three years where nobody checked anything. Three years with one incident, or three years with several. The number hides exactly the part you care about.

An operator in a hard hat and hi-vis vest beside a reach truck, reaching up to a pallet under high racking

What a years filter costs you

A hard filter on years does two things at once. It lets through people whose years tell you little. And it screens out people without testing anything, including some who might do the job well.

That second effect is easy to miss, because you never see the people you filtered out. In a market where most occupational groups are tight, it is worth asking whether a years filter is protecting quality, or just shrinking your pool.

We should be careful here too. For roles where skills are learned on the job, the research on how well structured methods work for inexperienced applicants is thin; the researchers themselves say they cannot yet tell. So we are not claiming that dropping the years filter automatically finds better people. We are saying the filter is weaker evidence than it looks.

Ask about the work instead

Our view: treat "three years on reach trucks" as the start of a question, not an answer.

A CV line reading reach truck operator, 2021 to 2024, with the three years ringed and led to three questions about the work.

Instead of checking the number, ask every candidate the same questions about the work itself. For example:

  • How did you do the work? "Describe the last time you operated a reach truck. What kind of warehouse was it, and what heights did you work at?"
  • What equipment and processes did you use? "Which types of trucks have you operated, and what did a normal shift look like?"
  • What checks or standards did you work under? "How did you check the truck before use, and what safety rules did your site have?"

These questions are illustrations, not a validated assessment. Write your own, tied to your site's requirements, and decide in advance what a strong, acceptable and weak answer looks like How to Run Structured Interviews at High Volume.

Those answers are still the candidate's own account. The certificate still needs to be verified, and competence can be demonstrated where that is safe and proportionate. But you will learn far more from three good questions than from one date range.

For staffing agencies

If you screen for clients, the years filter is often written into the order. It is worth a conversation. Ask the client's site supervisor what actually decides whether a reach truck driver works out on their site. Then screen for that, and send the client the evidence, not just the years.

Closing thought

Experience matters. It is context, it often comes with skills, and for some work it comes with certificates you cannot do without. But the number of years is a label, not evidence.

So here is a question for your next job ad: if you removed the years requirement and replaced it with three questions about the work, what would you learn that you do not know now?

Read next: Structured vs Unstructured Interviews: What the Research Shows, and What It Does Not explains the research behind these numbers in more depth.

The full evidence is in "A New Standard for Frontline Hiring" white paper download page.

FAQ

Does years of experience predict job performance?

Only weakly. On the revised 2022 figures by Sackett and colleagues, years of job experience has an average validity of 0.07 for predicting overall job performance, against 0.42 for structured interviews. These are averages across many studies, mostly outside the Netherlands, and they take nothing away from licences or certificates.

Should you drop a minimum-experience requirement?

Treat it as the start of a question, not an answer. A hard years filter lets through people whose years tell you little and screens out others without testing anything. Ask every candidate the same questions about the work, verify the certificates the role needs, and decide in advance what a strong answer looks like.

What should you ask a reach-truck driver instead of years?

Ask about the work itself: the last time they operated a reach truck, what kind of warehouse it was and at what heights, which trucks they have used, and how they checked the truck before use. Ask everyone the same questions and verify the certificate separately.

How Radius Hire does this

Radius Hire asks about the work instead of the years: the AI Interviewer puts role-specific questions to every applicant, and Match reads the answers against the requirements you wrote, so a candidate is judged on what they can do, not on a number of years.

Sources

  1. Sackett, P. R., Zhang, C., Berry, C. M., and Lievens, F. (2022). Journal of Applied Psychology, 107(11), 2040 to 2068. DOI 10.1037/apl0000994
  2. Sackett, P. R., Zhang, C., Berry, C. M., and Lievens, F. (2023). Industrial and Organizational Psychology, 16(3), 283 to 300. Open access. DOI 10.1017/iop.2023.24
  3. Schmidt, F. L., and Hunter, J. E. (1998). The validity and utility of selection methods in personnel psychology. Psychological Bulletin, 124(2), 262 to 274.
  4. Radius Hire (2026). A New Standard for Frontline Hiring. Sections 1.3, 3.3 and 3.6.